What are you looking for, homie?

Classic Book Review : Robert Aickman - The Unsettled Dust (1990)

Classic Book Review : Robert Aickman - The Unsettled Dust (1990)

There are essentially two kids of horror readers: the ones that need a monster at the end of the dark corridor and the ones that need the dark corridor to go on and on. Because a dark corridor is nothing but a dark corridor until you inject your own fears, brokenness and inadequacies in them. What happened to you will be infinitely more terrifying to you than anything else. Cult British author Robert Aickman was never interested in monsters, but he did love and understand that dark corridor.

And down that dark corridor we sure go in his short story collection The Unsettled Dust.

The Unsettled Dust is a collection of eight short stories ranging from sixteen to over eighty pages long. These short stories explore a range of topics that go from martial anxieties to survivor’s guilt by the way of the weight of grief. Ordinary ordeals that most people have to go through in their lifetimes, which Robert Aickman explores under the light of what it now referred to as quiet horror. The emotional and psychological states that distort reality as you’re experiencing hardship.

Nothing Needs To Happen

The title story is a prime example of Robert Aickman doing what he does best. Narrated from the perspective of an employee of an organization that preserves historic buildings, it tells the story of two sisters sharing a traumatic bond they never reveal. That bond is embodied by an omnipresent dust covering every inch of the house and by an inexplicable male apparition in one of the bedrooms. Olive and Agnes Brakespear once lived a better life, but that life is long gone.

Aickman uses a hint of supernatural in this story, but not enough to firmly camp it as a ghost story. There is definitely a ghost standing between Olive and Agnes, but the narrator never witnesses anything to settle whether the ghost is real or emotional and that tension in itself elicits dread. Is the narrator seeing things or is he affected by the obvious and heavy weight of the past between the two sisters? That uncertainty about what he'd just seen makes his visit at Clamber Court this unresolved reminiscence.

The longest story in the collection The Stains is one of Robert Aickman's most celebrated. It’s about a middle-aged widower meeting a vibrant young woman in the woods. They soon become lovers, but they are followed around by a strange lichen than seems to grow in their apartment as well as on their respective bodies. Even though they are happy and sexually fulfilled together, they already seem to be running out of time. The reason why is both right under their nose and totally unclear.

I don't understand why Stephen and Nell can't live the happily ever after together and that's what makes The Stains riveting. The two lovers are pursued by something akin to natural law. Not only the have an important age difference, but they are separated by a cultural difference that sexual promiscuity cannot entirely solve. Although Sephen is not interested in that cultural gap between them, it keeps growing and showing its presence until it become inevitable and terminal.

Wokeman, Wokeman

Alright, here's a hot take on Robert Aickman: is it me or he was a little woke before his time? Maybe he ignored himself because he was a turn-of-the-century British white man, but he did write great female characters struggling with quite contemporary issues. No Stronger than a Flower tells the story of a woman terrified by her spouse and using her physical image as a weapon to protect herself against his violent and growingly irrational demands. It's quite short, but brilliant.

Bind Your Hair tells the story of a woman stumbling upon a weird pagan underworld near the home of her fiancé. It explores the anxiety of having to marry someone you're not exactly passionate with for the sake of it as a woman in mid-century England. Clarinda Hartley has chosen the Dudley Carstairs as a husband almost in on principle because he looks harmless, but as the reality of their wedding is getting closer, the world as she understands it seems to be dislocating.

Robert Aickman also explores the idea of holding on to property longer than you should in the title story and in the awesomely liminal The Houses of the Russians. In these stories, property is burdened by past history and trauma. It doesn’t turn predatory, but it holds a weight that makes it difficult to move on from it. It keeps people prisoner of an invisible, but powerful melancholy that inflicts a stillness upon everything. In Aickman’s world, if you can attached to homes, you disappear into them.

*

The Unsettled Dust showcases a rich and nuanced imaginary walking a tight rope between psychological realism and supernatural horror. It can be challenging as it’s full of details, nuanced and mannerisms that can be difficult to relate to in the twenty-first century, but it’s also quite difficult not to like an author that doesn't feel the need to explain anything. Robert Aickman does not care whether you understand his stories or not, for as long as they live and grow inside you and that's cool with me.

7.5/10

* Follow me on Instagram , Bluesky and Substack to keep up with new posts *

A User-Friendly Guide to Unlistenable Music, Vol. 3

A User-Friendly Guide to Unlistenable Music, Vol. 3